Top 10 Best Toaster Oven for Polymer Clay

Photo of author
Written By Eshe

Hello, I’m Eshé the lady behind the blog. That’s me cooking on the set of The Hairy Bikers. I LOVE food and I don’t mean I really like it. I mean my whole world revolves around it.

Are you looking for an efficient and effective way to bake polymer clay pieces quickly?

A toaster oven might be just what you need. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at buying the best toaster oven for polymer clay and offer some tips on how to choose the right one for your needs.

Researching a toaster oven is a daunting task. You could find yourself lost in the number of brands, features, and reviews to try to find the best-rated toaster oven for polymer clay.

The Toaster Oven will cure your polymer clay. These are designed to let you complete your shaping and curing process with the touch of a button.

If you are in search of a polymer clay oven, then this article will be your guide as we have reviewed some of the best models.

Best Toaster Oven for Polymer Clay

  • Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven – Best Overall
  • COMFEE’ Toaster Oven Countertop – Best Budget
  • Toaster Oven by Mueller Austria – Best Value
  • Black+Decker Toaster Oven
  • Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven

If you are one of those people that love to make things out of polymer clay, then you might be looking for a toaster oven.

Baking polymer clay can be as easy as putting a pizza or dough stone on a baking sheet.

If you have never tried polymer clay before, I recommend learning how to bake with it from a professional bake sales or club. You will find that polymer clay does not heat up as quickly as other types of clay

This guide will help you to find the top 10 best toaster ovens for polymer clay in 2022 so that you don’t need to waste time finding out which is the right one for you.Shortcode

Let us discuss the ideal toaster oven for baking polymer clay.

1.Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven – Best Overall

TOSHIBA AC25CEW-BS Large 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven...

Check Price

This basic toaster oven is made of high-grade black stainless steel for durability. While using polymer clay or any other baking sheet, you can cook everything you want.

The Toshiba Toaster Oven offers a diverse and expanded range of features, offering you the ability to toast, bake, broil, or keep your clay warm.

No matter what you choose to cook, the extra-large interior is roomy enough to handle even the bigger items. It features ten cooking settings with adjustable temperatures from 150 – 400°F and allows you to bake many polymer clays at once.

This stylishly designed toaster oven includes cool-touch handles, dual-position racks for versatility.

The biggest feature of this unit is its ability to do polymer clay projects, and 10 cooking settings with adjustable temperatures from 150 – 400 degrees, Fahrenheit could satisfy all your daily cooking needs.

This toaster oven is best for polymer clay and is used widely in toasting, baking, and broiling. Bright digital display, easy-to-use control knobs, and dual position racks let you toast polymer clay in a better way.

The advanced technology makes the toaster oven even more energy-efficient, so you can save money on energy bills while enjoying using it.

With an easy-to-turn control level, you can adjust the cooking temperature. The nonstick interior ensures easy cleanup after use.

This Toaster Oven Includes a removable crumb tray, rotisserie kit and lifter, baking rack, baking pan, and a rack clamp

Why We Like it

  • 10 Cooking settings
  • Adjustable Control System
  • Can work for continuous 2 hours at 450 degrees F
  • Easy to Clean, due to Its Nonstick Interiors

2. COMFEE’ Toaster Oven Countertop – Best Budget

COMFEE' Toaster Oven Countertop, 4-Slice, Compact Size, Easy to...

Check Price

COMFEE toaster oven is an excellent addition to your cooking and baking tools. It allows you to bake, broil, toast, and reheat all depending on your preferences.

This convection toaster oven can handle most of your toasting needs with its compact and versatile design. It features a broil rack that expands the cooking area to accommodate larger foods and has 2 easy-to-use dial controls so you can bake polymer clay with a simple turn of the knob.

The versatile toaster oven has multiple features, including a 30-minute timer for precise toast shade preference and a stay-on feature for longer.

The convenience of the timer is designed for the at-home baker that needs to perfect their crusty polymer clay creations while still making a delicious meal.

Featuring a classic black and brushed stainless steel finish, this toaster oven fits easily on any countertop, which will bring elegance for a classic kitchen interior setup or even when using it outdoors.

The Comfee non-stick baking polymer clay toaster oven is perfectly designed for baking polymer clay. If you don’t have a lot of room, but want to bake large quantities of polymer clay at a time, the COMFEE will fit the bill nicely.

The Shade Selector dial will ensure you get just the right color on your baked polymer clay. With a wide temperature range, you will have the freedom to produce a variety of baked goods for your family and friends.

Why We Like it

  • Designed perfectly for baking polymer clay
  • Space-saving and perfect for small toasting projects
  • It has different toasting modes along with a dial control system
  • A 30 minutes timer is suitable for precise toast shade for large polymer items.

3. Toaster Oven by Mueller Austria – Best Value

Toaster Oven 4 Slice, Multi-function Stainless Steel Finish with...

Check Price

The Mueller Austria Stainless Steel Convection Toaster Oven not only looks beautiful, but it also cooks. The inside of the oven is made from high-quality stainless steel which means that the heat can be distributed more evenly.

It also includes a timer with precise toast settings along with stay-on functionality for things like baking polymer clay.

This toaster oven is more than a small appliance, it’s an essential tool for a variety of tasks. You can bake, roast, broil and toast with ease in this convenient countertop oven.

Its rear heat element rises from the back wall inside the unit to provide even heat distribution without hot spots.

This is the widely used toaster oven with even heating technology. Made of top-quality components and designed to function as a conventional oven, this unit is perfect for toasting anything like polymer clay for small projects.

It comes with a baking pan and rack and has a carry handle for easy placement in the kitchen or other locations.

This Toaster Oven is great for baking polymer clay. The top and bottom heating elements feature separate controls to ensure a custom fit, and the timer is programmable for consistent results every time.

This toaster oven is a great choice for baking your clay projects. This small oven combines the functionality of multiple appliances, the size of a toaster oven, but easily performs as large toaster ovens.

It even comes with a baking rack and baking pan, bonus.

Include 2 rack positions and included multi-purpose pan provide the versatility to have great results for all types of toasting tasks, while the stay-cool exterior lengthens the life of your new toaster.

Why We Like it

  • Multi-Functional
  • Dual Position Rack
  • User-Friendly Toaster Oven

Also Read: How To Preheat A Toaster Oven?

4. Black+Decker Toaster Oven – Best investment

BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Convection Oven, Stainless Steel, Curved...

Check Price

The Black & Decker Toaster Oven is equipped with Even Toast Technology which provides a steady temperature to evenly toast the clay for precise results.

The stylish toaster oven is the perfect appliance for every household. The unique features include a stainless steel design with an auto shut-off, an LCD and LED indicators for simple operation and a removable crumb tray for ease of use.

The toast dial features convenient and clear markings to accommodate a variety of toasting needs. The timer with stay-on functionality allows the user to pre-set toasting times or to start it up when the toast is ready.

This Toaster Oven with Even Toast Technology is an oven that provides perfect toast every single time. It works best for polymer clay.

A removable crumb tray for easy cleanup, and a power indicator light complete this impressive package. Its even-heating crumb tray and baking pan easily lift out for removal of crumbs and cleanup.

The toaster oven includes an oven rack that works great for drying polymer clay bezels, and the timer allows you to have complete control over your timer needs when working with polymer clay.

It includes an advanced heating element for consistent baking and an automatic toast boost setting for making thick pieces of polymer clay or toasting homemade items.

Why We Like it

  • Specially designed for even toasting
  • Works great for polymer clay
  • Toast the clay up to 450°F

5. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach 6-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven with Easy Reach...

Check Price

No matter how you slice it, its compact countertop toaster oven is an easy way to toast or bake a variety of polymer clays. With two rack positions and a handy bake pan, you can toast everything.

Easy-access roll-top doors provide safe, mess-free countertop access, so you’ll enjoy more convenient toasting and baking. It has a spacious interior for baking your favorite clay projects.

The Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven with Easy Reach Roll-Top Door is a great toaster oven for polymer clay.

The roll-top door allows you to easily access your work without fear of cutting your hands on the door. This is a must-have for any serious polymer clay artist.

This is the best toaster oven for polymer clay and its pan can also be used as a drip tray underneath your polymer clay.

You can even use the baking pan alone on top of the oven, for a second level when using the push molding technique, or opening the oven to drop a tiny amount of clay onto something you are baking.

The flexible polymer clay rack positions are ideal for baking plates and sheets of polymer clay. The Roll-top Door helps keep your hands away from hot surfaces

The roll-top door with an auto rise feature makes it easy to access your polymer clay creations.

The easy-to-clean stainless steel exterior features a sleek silver finish.

Why We Like it

  • Designed to make it easy for polymer clay projects
  • Easy access to Your Clay and Countertop due to the roll-top door
  • Easy to keep clean

6- BLACK + DECKER toaster oven TO3230SBD

BLACK+DECKER TO3230SBD 6-Slice Convection Countertop Toaster...

Check Price

This toaster oven has a good quality stainless steel body, giving it a solid and attractive look. The stainless steel body makes this oven more durable and long-lasting.

BLACK +DECKER toaster oven comes with four great cooking functions: broiling, toasting, baking, and keeping the clay warm. You can use any of these functions according to your needs. 

This toaster oven is widely used for baking clay and cooking other food items due to its large interior.  

This BLACK + DECKER toaster oven works on the principle of conventional heating. A high power conventional fan is fitted inside to circulate warm air throughout the oven. This warm air moving all around ensures evenly baking, broiling and toasting. 

Due to the conventional heating system, this oven works very fastly and consumes significantly less power for working. Less power consumption means less power bills and more money savings. 

One of the exciting features of this toaster oven is the 60-minutes timer that allows you to work efficiently while doing long polymer baking projects. 

Moreover, this advanced feature of the oven lets you get the perfect shape and colour of polymer clay. We love its large glass window that helps to view the food during the cooking process. 

BLACK + DECKER toaster has a stylish expanded body that can fit excellently on your countertop and gives a classy look to your kitchen interior. 

Why We like it

  • Conventional heating system 
  • Four cooking functions 
  • 60-minutes timer for baking projects 
  • Stylish, durable, and long-lasting 

7- Elite gourmet Maxi-Matic toaster oven 

Maxi-Matic Personal 2 Slice Countertop 15 Minute Timer Toaster...

Check Price

The elite gourmet maxi-matic toaster oven has a high-quality metal body that makes it durable, long-lasting and attractive

This toaster oven has a tempered glass door to see what’s happening inside and how much you need to cook. 

Elite gourmet maxi-matic toaster oven provides you with 3 cooking functions like broiling, baking and toasting. So, you can cook any meal evenly and fastly. 

The best feature we love of this toaster oven is a 15 minutes timer with auto shut off and a ring bell. This remarkable feature provides you with the comfort of working and enables you to perform different tasks at once without any hesitation. 

You can adjust the heating temperatures in this toaster oven that ensure safety and even cooking. A power indicator light in this modern oven indicates that the food has reached its required  temperature. 

This advanced toaster oven is very easy to handle because of its low weight and small size. When you place this metal oven on your countertop, it enhances the beauty of your kitchen. 

The maxi-matic toaster oven is perfect for polymer clay and is widely used worldwide for toasting and baking purposes because it allows you to have the exact shade and crispiness. 

This toaster oven includes accessories like a wire rack and baking pan for increasing the cooking surface. It helps you to cook large food items quickly. 

The crumbs tray in this oven collects the waste, and the non-stick lining prevents the sticking of food and makes it very easy to clean. 

The Elite gourmet maxi-matic toaster oven consumes significantly less power and works efficiently. This low power consumption saves your money on power bills. 

Why We like it 

  • Easy to clean and use
  • Less power consumption 
  • 15-minutes timer with auto shut off 
  • Good for compact storage 
  • Power indicating light 

8- AMACO craft/clay countertop oven 

AMACO Countertop Craft/Clay Oven, Black, 15 x 7 x 8 in

Check Price

AMACO countertop oven is made of good quality material that gives it durability and a classy appearance. 

This oven is simply perfect for baking polymer clay and other craft products that require high temperatures. 

With the help of this versatile and affordable craft/craft oven, you can easily make different polymer clay items at home. 

AMACO oven offers multiple exciting features, one of which we love is adjustable temperature. This oven can heat the polymer clay and other crafting products on a very high temperature up to 300 degrees Fahrenheit. 

This oven is more energy-efficient than a home oven because it consumes less power and saves money.

This oven’s unique and modern design makes it suitable for a compact space on your kitchen counter. It looks fantastic and fits almost all types of kitchen interiors. 

This AMACO craft and clay countertop oven have a vast interior and good capacity so that you can bake several craft products in the oven at once. 

Another amazing feature of this oven is the 30 minutes timer that helps you to perform different tasks in a short time. 

This AMACO oven has control knobs and adjustable racks that make it easy to handle and safe to use. The non-stick lining in the interior of this classy oven provides the ease of cleaning. 

Why We like it 

  • Perfect for baking clay and craft goods. 
  • 30 minutes timer 
  • Heating temperature up to 300 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Affordable and easy to use 

9- Cuisinart toaster oven 

Cuisinart TOB-80N Compact Toaster Oven Broiler, Stainless Steel

Check Price

The Cuisinart toaster oven is an incredible addition to your kitchen because of its elegant design and best quality material. 

This toaster oven offers a variety of cooking functions like broiling, toasting, baking and keeping the clay warm. You can choose any of these functions according to your preference. 

The Cuisinart toaster oven is ideal for compact spaces because of its small size and lightweight. You can place this oven on the kitchen countertop or anywhere in the house. 

The interior of this oven has a large room for cooking delectable meals and baking many polymer clays simultaneously. 

This oven has an adjustable temperature setting that allows you to set the temperature according to your need. This oven is best for performing polymer clay crafts..

Unlike other toaster ovens available at high prices, this oven is exceptionally affordable.. This oven has a hands free auto slide-out rack that makes it very convenient. 

The brushed stainless steel door and easy to hold handle make this oven a worth buying product.

This ultra-modern oven works very efficiently and consumes less power. Less power consumption means you can save money on electricity bills. 

This Cuisinart toaster oven has a non-stick interior that prevents the sticking of foods and clay inside and provides the ease of cleaning. 

Furthermore, this advanced oven includes an auto slide-out crumbs tray, baking tray and a broiling rack. 

Why we like it 

  • Counter friendly and best for compact space
  • Non-stick interior 
  • Hands-free auto slide-out rack
  • Adjustable temperature setting 
  • Perfect for baking clays  

10- NUWAVE Digital Air Fryer 

Nuwave Brio 8-Qt Air Fryer, Powerful 1800W, Easy-to-Read Cool...

Check Price

NUWAVE digital air fryer is a well-designed cooking appliance that serves the same as a toaster oven does. 

The most prominent feature of this oven that we like the most is its 100 pre-programmed menu presets for grilling, toasting, broiling, reheating, baking, roasting, dehydrating, defrosting, and many more. It totally depends on your preferences and which program you choose. 

The additional 50 memory slots in this versatile air fryer allow you to save and recall your favorite recipes. So, you can use this feature for cooking your favorite food conveniently. 

The roomy interior of this air fryer has the capacity to cook large meals. Therefore, this oven is perfect for a medium to large family. 

This NUWAVE digital air fryer has digital temperature monitors that provide you with the ease of cooking. You can set the doneness temperature of the item you have placed in the fryer and do your other tasks. 

This air fryer’s digital temperature monitoring system avoids the overcooking and burning of foods. So, you can do multiple tasks while baking clay or cooking meals for your family. 

Another incredible feature of this air fryer that we love is the adjustable temperature setting. It provides a vast temperature range from 50 degrees Fahrenheit to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. This feature makes this air fryer perfect for baking polymer clay and other crafting materials. 

Besides baking crafting materials, you can use this air fryer for cooking delicious foods every day. You can adjust the temperature in a 5 Fahrenheit increment for easy and convenient cooking. 

The Linear Thermal Technology in this air fryer detects the temperature changes and ensures that the food is cooking at your desired temperature 120 times per second. This temperature adjustment helps to bake and toast the polymer clay at its exact temperature. 

This amazingly designed air fryer has superheated air and efficient airflow, perfect for cooking crispy and healthy meals. The air circulation in the fryer guarantees that the food or clay is baked evenly. 

Nuwave digital air fryer has a digital white display that is very easy to read. You can read and select the temperature or cooking program even if there is no light in the kitchen. 

This air fryer is very easy to operate, and the response is immediate. Unlike ordinary air fryers and toaster ovens, this air fryer is affordable and works excellently. 

The reversible stainless steel racks in the air fryer have a non-stick lining that ensures easy cleanup. These racks are also dishwasher safe. So, if you are busy and don’t have time to clean them, you can put them into your dishwasher for cleaning. 

Why We like it 

  • 100 pre-programmed menu presets
  • Easy to operate 
  • Adjustable temperature setting 
  • Perfect for medium to large family 
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe racks 
  • Linear Thermal technology for temperature monitoring

What is Polymer Clay and its Usage?

Polymer clay is best known for its use as an alternative to wood for making props, pictures, dolls, and model kits. Polymer clay can be molded into nearly any shape and has been used by artists for a long time.

The versatility of polymer clay is unmatched. You can use it to create almost anything you can think of in their right, from figures to helmets, swords, jewelry, letters, or even cookie boxes.

It is highly flexible yet holds its shape like nothing else. But it does not get in the way or take away from your creativity in making your projects come to life.

The benefits of using polymer clay are numerous in terms of the varied materials that can be sculpted from this medium; from fine ceramics to larger sculptures.

The properties of polymer clay make it perfect for all sorts of outdoor playtime activities.

Toasting in the Oven

Proper heat is the key to creating beautiful results with polymer clay. Heat the pieces to create air bubbles within the pieces, which helps the polymer clay flow more easily through the oven.

Use the convection method if you prefer airy effects in artwork instead of the more traditional bake method, which involves placing a single layer of baked polymer clay on a flat surface and covering it with another layer of clay even after the top layer has been removed.

This method leaves behind a more even layer of polymer clay

Buying Guide for Toaster Oven for Polymer Clay

There are several factors to take into account when selecting the best toaster oven for your home. Polymer clay is an impressive material that can be blown into shapes and sizes at will by most hobbyists.

To get the most out of your clay, you will need to make sure that it is well protected during the firing process and handled carefully after the fact.

The toaster oven for polymer clay takes a lot of things into account when selecting one. Many factors go into choosing the best toaster oven and there are even some basic things you should be aware of before purchasing one.

You will want to know how much heat you want on your polymer clay piece, how hot will the clay be when you bake it, how long will it take to fully warm up, and if it will hold its shape when being cut. Polymer clay pieces are easy to clean as they don’t need any special drying process.

Here are some important considerations when choosing the right toaster oven for polymer clay.


The first thing to look at when searching for an oven for polymer clay is the material itself. There are various materials used in toasters, as well as different styles.

You want to make sure that the toaster you select is made from materials that are heat-resistant and durable enough to withstand the typical use and abuse that comes with working with polymer clay.


Another factor you should consider is the design. Most toasters have two handles and one piece of metal or plastic that holds the surface against the cooking surface.

Different brands use different methods to heat their cookware, so this is an important consideration when buying toaster ovens for polymer clay.


The size of the toaster oven plays an important role when deciding on what size to buy, particularly if you are going to be using your toaster regularly. If you only use your toaster occasionally, then the smaller models will be adequate.

However, if you plan to regularly use your toaster for baking polymer clay, go for the larger models.


If you are creating a toaster oven for polymer clay, you need to understand that the price should be reasonable. Polymer clay is very expensive to make, and the toaster ovens are very expensive to buy as well.

Because of this, it’s important to understand how much this piece of equipment is going to cost you. Make sure you consider what you plan to do with it before you decide on a price.

Temperature Control System

A toaster comes with a control system that allows you to set the temperature of your toaster according to what you want. On the other hand, button-based ovens have just one control setting that you need to know about.

A built-in temperature sensor is also an excellent addition; it can sense whether the center of the toaster is around 350 degrees or below, allowing you to avoid using too much heat if you don’t want to get toast that’s too crisp or soggy on the inside.

Heating Method

The best type of heating method for your toaster oven is convection.

This method of heat transfer gets the most out of any given piece of baked goods, and it can definitely match up to conventional forms of heat transfer such as gas or electricity.

Convection baking uses much less energy than in other methods, and it’s more adaptable to changing weather conditions.

Study the Customer Reviews

The best toaster oven for polymer clay is a much-awaited purchase for most people. While you might be tempted to go with a cheaper model, there is a big difference in performance and quality when shopping for a high-end toaster.

Check the reviews from customers or your friends before buying the toaster oven for polymer clay, in this way you can better understand the functions and can make a strong decision



Baking polymer clay can be tricky. You need a temperature that is low but still sufficient to bake the clay. The proper ratio of water to clay is also important, too much water and the clay will be tough and crack, too little and it will be crumbly.

We all want excellent results when it comes to our clay projects, whether that means creating elegant tokens or baking tasty treats. Each type of clay has its own specific needs when it comes to toaster ovens.

That’s why we have taken the liberty of testing a wide range of toaster ovens to determine which will best meet your needs.

As you may suspect, there isn’t one correct type of toaster oven for all types of clays. Each toaster oven has unique features tailored to meet the needs of a specific type of polymer clay.

Leave a Comment