How to Thaw Uncrustables

In today’s fast-paced world, convenience often takes center stage in our daily routines. Amidst busy schedules and on-the-go lifestyles, frozen snacks like Uncrustables have gained immense popularity for their quick, no-fuss nourishment.

Uncrustables, those delightful crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwiches neatly packed in the freezer aisle, offer a delightful combination of nostalgia and ease.

However, to truly savor their flavors and textures, it’s crucial to master the art of proper thawing.

Whether you’re a parent preparing a lunchbox treat or simply craving a hassle-free snack, understanding the various thawing methods for Uncrustables ensures that each bite is as delectable as the first.

In this article, we’ll delve into the yummy world of uncrustables and answer the most burning question: how to thaw uncrustables

We’ll discover science and techniques behind thawing Uncrustables effectively, preserving their taste, and maintaining their appeal in every situation.

History of Uncrustables

The history of Uncrustables dates back to the late 1990s, when the company J.M. Smucker Co. introduced a novel solution to the age-old problem of crusty sandwich edges.

In 1998, Smucker’s launched Uncrustables, a brand that offered pre-made, crust-free peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.

The concept quickly gained traction, particularly among parents seeking convenient lunchbox options for their children.

Uncrustables provided a solution to busy mornings and on-the-go meals, eliminating the need to painstakingly trim crusts while still delivering the familiar comfort of a PB&J sandwich.

Over the years, Uncrustables have evolved to include various flavors and fillings, catering to different dietary preferences and tastes.

How to Thaw Uncrustables

Thawing Uncrustables properly is essential to ensure that they retain their taste, texture, and safety. There are a few methods you can use, depending on your time constraints and preferences:

Method 1: Rub uncrustable with your hands

Although it may sound silly, you can try it, and it works every time. After uncrustables storing in the fridge to make them last longer, you can massage them between your hands before eating them. 

The friction in your palms will produce heat, which will gradually heat your uncrustables. As a result, the temperature goes up, and the meal thaws in a relatively short time.

Method 2: Using the Freezer

You may store the remaining uncrustables in the fridge and freeze the ones you want to eat right away. It keeps sandwiches fresh in the freezer; you can bring them outside and substitute them with those in the refrigerator if you need these. This approach allows you to defrost and enjoy the delicious uncrustables quickly.

Method 3: Use sunlight.

You can use the sun’s energy in this approach because we all know how cars warm up very quickly. Consequently, take the food out of the fridge and put it in your vehicle. 

The natural heat of the sun will thaw the uncrushable fast, allowing you to consume it. Furthermore, you need to check the packing of food products.

Method 4: Use Hot Water

In this accessible and effective technique, use hot water to thaw your sandwich. But, keep the goods inside their primary wrapping like the previous approach. 

It would be best if you had a warmed water bowl that’s not too hot after taking your uncrustable out from the fridge. Dip the packed sandwich into the dish. At a specific time, this heat will defrost the meal so that you can eat it.

Method 5: Use refrigerator 

By using your refrigerator, you can easily thaw the uncrustables. Place the desired number of Uncrustables in the refrigerator. Allow them to thaw slowly in the refrigerator for several hours or overnight.

After this certain time, take them out and enjoy. This method ensures even thawing and keeps the sandwiches chilled.

Method 6: Invest money in heating pads.

Lastly, a heating pad is an excellent technique to thaw your uncrustable. You can quickly defrost the uncrustable with the help of these heating pads. 

Remove the food from the fridge and place it on the heating pad; the heat will gradually defrost it.

Method 7: Choose a warmer place 

Keeping the uncrustables in a warmer place is another best way to thaw them quickly. You can choose any warm space such as a sunny window or a countertop away from direct heat. 

Warmer place will provide a gentle and consistent warmth for thawing this treat. All you have to do is, choose the place, remove the desired number of uncrustables from the packaging and place them on the plate.  

Now place the plate in the chosen warm spot. Allow it to sit for approximately 2 hours or until they are thawed completely. Once done, the uncrustables are ready to eat.

Method 8: Wrap them in a towel 

Wrapping a towel around is a super easy method of thawing uncrustables. The towel around the uncrustables helps to insulate the sandwiches and facilitates a gentle thawing process. To thaw Uncrustables by wrapping them in a towel,follow these simple steps; 

  • Take the desired number of frozen Uncrustables out of the freezer and remove them from their packaging.
  • Wrap each Uncrustable individually or collectively in a clean kitchen towel. Make sure the towel completely covers the sandwiches.
  • Place the wrapped Uncrustables in a warm and dry location, away from any direct heat sources.
  • Allow the sandwiches to sit wrapped in the towel for approximately 1 to 2 hours, or until they have thawed completely.
  • Unwrap the Uncrustables and enjoy

Method 9: At room temperature 

Lastly, thawing the Uncrustables at room temperature is an effective technique. All you need to do is, Remove the desired number of Uncrustables from the freezer. Place them on a plate or a clean surface at room temperature.

Let them sit for approximately 30 minutes to an hour, depending on the ambient temperature. This method is faster than refrigerator thawing but still allows for even thawing.

How long does it take to thaw uncrustables? 

The average time it takes to thaw Uncrustables can vary depending on the thawing method and the temperature of the environment. If you thaw Uncrustables in the refrigerator, it may take several hours or overnight for them to completely thaw.

Thawing at room temperature typically takes around 30 minutes to an hour, depending on the ambient temperature. If you choose to use the microwave for a quick thaw, it can take as little as 10 to 20 seconds per sandwich.

Is it safe to thaw uncrustables in the microwave?

Yes, it is safe to thaw Uncrustables in the microwave, but there are certain precautions you should take to ensure the best results. When using the microwave to thaw Uncrustables, it’s important to use the defrost setting or low power setting rather than full power.

Thawing on low power or the defrost setting prevents the sandwich from becoming too warm too quickly, which can cause uneven thawing and potentially affect the texture and taste of the bread and fillings.

Additionally, it’s recommended to thaw the Uncrustable in short intervals, typically around 10-15 seconds, and to flip the sandwich during each interval to ensure even thawing.

Overheating the sandwich can result in the fillings becoming too runny or the bread becoming tough.

Can you toast uncrustables?

Yes, you can toast Uncrustables. Toasting an Uncrustable can add a delicious twist to the classic sandwich and provide a satisfying crunch.

To toast an Uncrustable, start by removing it from its packaging. Preheat a toaster or toaster oven to a medium setting.

Place the Uncrustable in the toaster or toaster oven, making sure it is centered and secure. 

Toast the sandwich for about 1 to 2 minutes, or until the bread is golden brown and the filling is warmed through.

Keep a close eye on the toasting process to prevent burning. Once toasted, allow the Uncrustable to cool for a moment before eating.

Can you thaw uncrustables in a lunch box? 

Yes, you can thaw uncrustables in a lunch box. To thaw Uncrustables in a lunch box, all you need to do is,  place the frozen sandwiches in the lunch box and close it securely.

Leave the lunch box at room temperature for a couple of hours, or until the sandwiches have thawed completely.

It’s important to note that this method may take longer than other thawing methods and the sandwiches may not thaw as evenly.

Why do uncrustables have to be frozen?

Uncrustables are frozen to maintain their freshness, quality, and to extend their shelf life. Freezing the sandwiches helps preserve the ingredients, including the bread, peanut butter, and jelly filling, preventing spoilage and maintaining their taste and texture.

Freezing may also inhibits the growth of bacteria and microorganisms, ensuring food safety.

By freezing Uncrustables, they can be stored for an extended period and easily thawed when needed, providing a convenient and ready-to-eat option for meals or snacks.

Homemade Uncrustable Sandwiches

Creating homemade Uncrustable-style sandwiches is a great way to customize your snacks while enjoying the convenience of a ready-to-eat treat. Here’s how you can make your own homemade version:


  • Bread slices (white, whole wheat, or your preferred type)
  • Peanut butter or any nut/seed butter of your choice
  • Jelly, jam, or preserves (any flavor you prefer)


  • Prepare the Fillings:
    • Start by spreading a thin layer of peanut butter on one side of a bread slice. Make sure not to spread it all the way to the edges.
    • On another slice of bread, spread a layer of jelly, jam, or preserves on one side.
  • Assemble the Sandwich:
    • Place the slice with peanut butter (spread side up) on top of the slice with jelly (spread side down). Press gently to adhere the two slices together.
  • Cutting:
    • Use a round cutter or the rim of a glass to cut out the sandwich into a circular shape. This will mimic the Uncrustables’ iconic shape.
    • Press down firmly while cutting to seal the edges.
  • Sealing the Edges:
    • To prevent the sandwich from coming apart, you can use a fork to press down and crimp the edges of the sandwich. This helps create a seal similar to the store-bought Uncrustables.

Do uncrustables go bad? 

Yes, Uncrustables can go bad if they are not stored properly or if they exceed their recommended shelf life.

While freezing helps to prolong their freshness, they can still spoil if stored for too long or under unfavorable conditions. Therefore, it’s important to check the expiration date on the packaging and adhere to it. 

Once thawed, Uncrustables should be consumed within a certain timeframe, typically within 48 hours if refrigerated. 

If you notice any signs of spoilage such as off odors, mold growth, or changes in texture or color, it is best to discard the Uncrustables to ensure food safety.

How do uncrustables not get soggy? 

Uncrustables are designed to not go soggy due to a combination of factors in their preparation and packaging.

The bread used in Uncrustables is typically made to be slightly thicker and sturdier than regular sandwich bread. This helps the bread maintain its texture even after thawing.

Moreover, the fillings, such as peanut butter and jelly, are often spread thinly and evenly to avoid excessive moisture buildup.

The freezing process also plays a crucial role – by freezing the sandwiches at a very low temperature, the moisture within the sandwich turns into ice crystals, minimizing the potential for sogginess upon thawing.

What flavours of uncrustables are available? 

Uncrustables come in a variety of flavors to cater to different preferences. While availability may vary depending on your location and the specific product line, here are some common flavors of Uncrustables:

  • Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly
  • Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam
  • Peanut Butter & Honey:
  • Reduced Sugar Peanut Butter & Grape Spread
  • Peanut Butter & Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut Spread

Frequently asked questions  

How Long Can You Keep Uncrustables Out of the Freezer?

Sandwiches should consume within 6-8 hours of defrosting. Make sure you don’t keep it out for more than 24 hours. However, if you keep it in the refrigerator, it will last for about two days.

What Happens When You Microwave Peanut Butter?

It’s necessary to understand that peanut butter has no moisture, but it has a lot of oil, and a microwave can effectively heat oil. The heat can easily reach the boiling point of water.

How do you air fry uncrustables?

You don’t need to thaw the sandwiches before air frying them. Carefully unwrap and place one frozen sandwich in the air fryer for 5-10 minutes at 350-400 ℉, one of the quickest solutions, you can keep a box of them in the freezer and air-fried them whenever the child wants a great lunch or snack.

What is the best way to make a frozen uncrustable?

Place the uncrustables on a baking or cooling sheet, spreading them out. Place the sheet in the freezer and freeze for at least 8 hours. The next morning, place the frozen uncrustables in a massive zip lock freezer bag. Take the uncrustables out as required; they can even thaw in the lunchbox.

Is uncrustables healthy?

Uncrustables are convenient and enjoyable, and they may be considered a particularly healthy food option. While they provide a source of protein and some essential nutrients, they also contain added sugars, refined carbohydrates, and may lack dietary fiber. That’s why it is recommended to consume Uncrustables in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

What is the alternative to uncrustables? 

A homemade peanut butter and jelly sandwich made with whole grain bread and natural peanut butter can be a healthier alternative to Uncrustables, offering more control over ingredients and providing additional nutritional benefits.

Can you put uncrustables in an air fryer?

It is not recommended to put Uncrustables in an air fryer as the high heat and circulating air may cause the sandwiches to become overly crispy or burn, potentially affecting their texture and taste.

What else can you make with uncrustables?

Beyond their traditional form, Uncrustables can serve as versatile ingredients for creative culinary endeavors. They can be chopped into cubes and added to yogurt parfaits for a delightful crunch. Transform them into bite-sized French toast sticks by dipping them in a cinnamon-infused egg mixture before cooking. For a sweet twist, blend them into milkshakes for a unique and nostalgic flavor.


In the world of quick and convenient snacks, Uncrustables stand out as a testament to innovation and practicality.

By mastering the art of proper thawing, you unlock the full potential of these crustless wonders.

Whether you choose the gradual refrigerator method, the room temperature option for urgency, or the careful approach of the microwave, the key lies in balance – preserving taste, texture, and safety.

With Uncrustables, a well-thawed delight is just a few steps away, ensuring a tasty, hassle-free treat every time.

Leave a Comment